I'll go with Emma's "divorce" theory first, but there's a part of me that thinks it might be this:
You post anti-CofS sentiments and probably harbor thoughts of having CofS disbanded. Then you find out that some of the people are NICE, and you don't want to hurt THEM. ("You" in this case means "One", anyone.)
But anyone in the CofS is part of the organism/organization which is forwarding evil intentions and actions towards their own members, staff as well as outsiders.
The calls are creating conflict in self, or emotional rollercoastering, or bewilderment.
I wouldn't put it past the CofS (with David Miscavige at the helm making up these ideas) that they are making these calls SPECIFICALLY to the critic community just to shake things up.
It's just more of their brainwashing, or causing of emotional rollercoastering in others.
The CofS is just a bunch of creeps. When someone leaves, they can have my sympathies... and not one moment before that.